Jewelry Appraisals from Angie’s List


Angie's List, the nation's leading provider of consumer reviews, asked highly rated jewelry experts about appraisals.


An appraisal is important because in the event your item is lost, damaged or stolen, you'll have a detailed description of the piece.

  • An appraiser inspects the item to make sure it's wearable and that there is no damage. The appraisal marks every detail (measurements, number of stones, type of metal, weight, etc.)
  • Your appraisal should also include a photograph and a replacement value – what it would cost to recreate the piece.
  • An appraiser can help separate the valuable jewelry from the costume jewelry.

The appraisal process:

  • Bring in the item, not a picture, for the appraiser to examine.
  • Bring the appraiser copies of any sales receipts or other documentation you have about the items being appraised.
  • Tell the appraiser anything you know about the item's origin or where it was purchased.
  • The appraiser will then take a few days to research the item's history and the marketplace.
  • You should receive a written report describing the item itself, the reasons for its valuation, and which type of value was done, for example – replacement value, fair market value or market value.

How do you know what to appraise?

  • Costume jewelry/base metal/plated – not worth appraising
  • “Real” metal but not expensive – describe and photograph it for your records, but don't appraise.
  • “Real” stones/metal that couldn't easily afford to replace within 12 months – get an appraisal and get it insured.  If you'd have to save up to replace it, it's worth the appraisal and insurance rider.

Angie's List Tips: Hiring an appraiser

Appraising jewelry for resale or insurance can be a challenge. It's important to know whether a diamond or stone is real in order to get an accurate estimate of value. Some fakes are difficult to spot. Therefore, it's wise to have a professional appraise any jewelry of value.

  • Start by defining your objective: Do you want an appraisal done for insurance purposes? For estate purposes? To find out your piece's fair market value?
  • Work with a jewelry appraiser who has been trained and certified:  Ask if the appraiser is certified by such organizations as the Gemological Institute of America and the American Gem Society. Pick someone who has been in the business for a while with a physical address.
  • Steer clear of an appraiser who charges a percentage of the appraised value:  Hourly fees or flat rates are acceptable. Expect to pay anywhere from 25 to 65 dollars per item. A good appraiser should review all items and establish a rate with the customer before beginning the process. Money saving tip: It can also more cost effective to bring in a number of pieces at once, rather than appraising them individually.
  • Appraisals should not take much more than a day, so be wary if the appraiser wants to keep your jewelry much longer than that. Most appraisers recommend making an appointment and will go over your items with you on-site. If you do leave your jewelry, request a receipt that itemizes and describes each piece.

Tips to manage your valuables:

  • Preserve your valuables. Have your items cleaned and checked annually.
  • Keep the item in their original state. Know that altering a piece may lower its value.
  • Consider getting your item re-appraised every three to five years. For items in highly volatile markets, its best to get them re-appraised annually.
  • Keep the descriptions of your jewelry in a location separate from the actual jewels. A good place is with your homeowner's insurance policy. For jewelry handed down through the family, add a description of where the piece came from and keep it with your appraisal information so the next generation can know it's significance.